About Sarah And Co

Welcome Home with Sarah & Co!

Sarah Fetterley 414.617.6756

Sarah Leinweber 414.704.2208

Sarah & Co. began with the desire to take a client-driven, collaborative approach to real estate. Focusing on fully utilizing our market knowledge and vast experience allows us to form a trusted team, capable of working through complex negotiations to deliver positive results

The home buying and selling experience is about YOU. The best way we can guide and advise our clients is by being REALTORS® who listen and are professional, knowledgeable and accessible from beginning to end. Just as no two people are the same; no two transactions are the same.Our promise to you is to meet your individual needs and to provide you with a positive real estate experience. Whether you are purchasing your very first home or selling your tenth, we will tailor the entire process to ensure all of your unique needs are met in a manner that works best for you.

Our client-first strategy allows us to draw on our years of market experience, tenacious negotiation skills and strong eye for staging in an atmosphere that is comfortable and confident. We rely on our track record of strong client-relationships and recognition for our hard work, including membership in Shorewest REALTORS® Executive Club, to lead our path going forward. With this approach, along with over $60 million in sales and the support from Shorewest REALTORS® award-winning team, Sarah & Co. is ready to welcome you home!


Sarah Leinweber

Sarah Leinweber

One of my favorite aspects of working with real estate clients is the chance to use my background in both financial consulting and human resources. I truly enjoy the technical and detail-oriented aspects of working with numbers and spreadsheets but find even more satisfaction working with people and helping them navigate the challenges of a home purchase or sale.

Having grown up in Whitefish Bay, I share with clients my first-hand experience with the Milwaukee area and all that it offers. As a graduate of the School of Business at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, Divine Savior Holy Angels High School in Milwaukee and St. Monica School in Whitefish Bay, I also have a personal understanding of educational opportunities that are available.

After spending over 15 years in the Chicago area, my husband and I decided to move our family back to Wisconsin. We enjoy spending time with friends and family in the North Shore as well as at our Lake Michigan cottage just north of Milwaukee, watching our childrens’ school and sporting events and helping in the community. I currently serve as the Vice President of the Whitefish Bay Public Library Board of Directors and am involved with Impact100 while my husband is on the board of Bookworm Gardens.  We so appreciate all that the Milwaukee area offers and are glad to be home!

  • Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist- CLHMS

Sarah Fetterley

Sarah Fetterley

I bring over 15 years of previous successful sales experience in commercial title insurance and pharmaceutical sales industries—but real estate is in my blood! I come from a long line of successful agents. Both my brother and sister are licensed agents in the state and my mother enjoyed a 30+ year career in real estate, the last 10 of which were as Sales Director of the North Shore office of Shorewest. I couldn’t stay away any longer so I made the switch to real estate sales in 2013.

My family and I have very strong ties to the community. My husband, Will and I were born and raised in Milwaukee and are so happy to be raising our two girls in Whitefish Bay. I am very active in Whitefish Bay Schools PTO, the Wisconsin Breast Cancer Show House and the Milwaukee Yacht Club.

I am very familiar with everything this amazing city has to offer and believe it is truly a hidden gem. I look forward to partnering with you in your next real estate transaction!


    Exec 2020


Home Valuation Report